Back to Blogs

Choosing the right CMS: Contentstack for agile businesses vs. Sitecore CMS

The Contentstack TeamOct 18, 20233 min read

Talk to an expert

about something you read on this page

Contact an expert

Selecting the right content management system (CMS) can make a difference in your organization's online presence. A CMS will directly affect user experience, search engine optimization, and overall digital strategy. 

In this blog, we'll delve into headless CMS and explore two popular options: Sitecore CMS and Contentstack. We'll provide a basic understanding of both CMS platforms. Then, we'll cover transitioning from Sitecore to Contentstack.

Selecting the right CMS

As mentioned, your chosen CMS will significantly affect overall user experience, SEO, and digital strategy. Sitecore CMS may be a good choice for organizations; however, if you prefer an agile, flexible, and scalable content management strategy, Contentstack is an excellent option.

A headless CMS like Contentstack ensures consistent content delivery across various devices while maintaining optimal user experience. Additionally, it can improve website search engine rankings and contribute to the overall success of your digital initiatives.

Sitecore CMS: Catering to the needs of enterprise organizations

Sitecore CMS is a widely used platform designed for enterprise businesses. It offers robust personalization and marketing automation tools. Its strengths include:


Sitecore CMS allows businesses to create personalized user experiences based on individual user preferences and behavior.

Marketing automation

Sitecore enables organizations to streamline their marketing operations through powerful features like email marketing, lead scoring, and analytics.

Support for complex scenarios 

Businesses with intricate organizational structures will find Sitecore's multisite and multi-language functionalities extremely beneficial.

Despite these advantages, Sitecore CMS may be overwhelming for some businesses. This is especially true for those seeking a more straightforward, headless CMS experience.

Contentstack: The modern CMS for agile enterprise businesses

Contentstack is a headless CMS designed to cater to organizations desiring a more elegant and flexible content management strategy. Here are some core benefits of using Contentstack.

Headless architecture

Contentstack has a headless architecture. This allows developers to use their preferred programming languages and frameworks while separating the content from the presentation layer. This results in a smoother integration process with various devices and platforms.

Flexibility and scalability 

Contentstack's modular design allows businesses to quickly adapt and scale their content strategy according to changing market dynamics.

Ease of use

With its user-friendly interface and extensive documentation, Contentstack make it easier for marketers and content creators to work without extensive technical knowledge.

The significance of Sitecore XP 10.4's end-of-life

Sitecore is a popular CMS known for its robust website content management and digital marketing capabilities. However, it's crucial to acknowledge the end of life of Sitecore XP 10.4. 

Why is this important? It means the company will no longer provide support or updates for this version. This may have severe consequences for your organization, including: 

  • lack of support leaves your CMS vulnerable to security breaches and technical difficulties, potentially leading to downtime and losing vital data, 

  • your platform will gradually become outdated without updates, impairing your ability to leverage emerging trends and technologies.

Implications for existing Sitecore users and businesses

For businesses that continue to use Sitecore XP 10.4, the risks and limitations that stem from the end-of-life are something to pay attention to. These implications include:

Increased security risks 

Without ongoing support and security patches, your Sitecore platform may become a potential target for hackers and vulnerable to security risks.

Reduced innovation and performance 

As new technologies and practices emerge, an outdated platform hinders business growth, diminishing your competitive edge in the market.

Costly upgrades 

Eventually, migrating to a newer version of Sitecore or an alternative platform becomes inevitable. The process can be time-consuming and costly.

Because of these issues, it's no wonder more businesses are transitioning to a headless CMS like Contentstack.

Headless CMS vs. traditional CMS

CMSes serve as the backbone of digital asset management for businesses around the globe. They fall into two main categories. They can be headless CMSes like Contentstack or traditional CMSes like Sitecore.

A headless CMS is built on an API-first architecture and provides greater flexibility and adaptability than a traditional CMS. It allows content creators to manage content without knowing the technical details of implementation. 

The headless CMS decouples content management from the presentation layer. This enables developers to work with a variety of digital channels efficiently. These include websites, mobile apps, and other customer touchpoints.

On the other hand, a traditional CMS typically couples content management with the visual presentation layer of a single website. As a result, traditional CMS options like Sitecore provide easy-to-use templates and drag-and-drop features for designing visually appealing web pages. However, this coupling limits the flexibility of content storage, making it harder to deliver content to multiple channels.

Advantages and disadvantages

Headless CMS advantages

  • Flexibility in content delivery to various platforms

  • Greater control over the presentation layer

  • Better performance as it relies on APIs

  • Quick response to changes in technology

Headless CMS disadvantages

  • More challenging to set up than traditional CMS

  • Requires a strong development team

  • Often lacks front-end user interface out of the box

Traditional CMS advantages

  • Pre-built templates for designing web pages

  • Drag-and-drop functionality for easy use

  • More appealing to non-technical users

  • Quicker to launch new websites

Traditional CMS disadvantages

  • Limited flexibility in content delivery

  • Lower performance compared to headless CMS

  • Slower to respond to technology advances

Contentstack's key features and benefits

Contentstack has notable features and advantages that make it stand out as a digital experience platform (DXP) of choice.

Real-time content management

Without extensive front-end development work, businesses can quickly edit and update content across various digital platforms. This feature saves time and resources by empowering content creators to make changes and see the results instantly.


Developers can leverage their preferred languages and front-end framework. This empowers them to build, iterate, and deploy projects quickly and efficiently.


Contentstack's headless nature ensures it remains a highly flexible and scalable solution. The platform works seamlessly with various digital assets and is compatible with numerous other digital media. This enables businesses to pivot and grow as needed.

Marketing automation

Contentstack's marketing automation features integrate with multiple digital marketing systems. This makes it easy for businesses to automate their marketing campaigns and streamline lead generation processes.

Gartner Magic Quadrant

Contentstack has been recognized in the Gartner Magic Quadrant. This reflects Contentstack's commitment to providing an innovative and reliable digital experience platform. It's also a testament to the platform's ability to effectively serve the needs of businesses of all sizes.

Contentstack case studies and testimonials

Contentstack is making real-world impacts globally daily by helping organizations achieve their goals. Here are a couple of examples.

RetailMeNot Inc.

RetailMeNot Inc., an online savings and promotional site, chose Contentstack because it needed a user-friendly CMS that let people access and modify content efficiently and consistently. 

Results included:

  • Faster delivery of experience and changes

  • Consistent management method for all content types

  • Reduced need for maintenance and reusable integrations

"Contentstack has allowed us to consolidate a lot of things into a single place that is much more user-friendly than previous tools were," said Gary Newcomb, principal engineer. "It's a lot faster to get new experiences and fixes out to our users, and it provides us with a much smaller set of integrations in our stack that our engineers must maintain." Read the complete "RetailMeNot creates omnichannel content at light speed" to learn more.


Cartier, the iconic French luxury brand, chose a headless CMS strategy to exploit the possibilities of reusing content to create a consistent, premium brand experience while remaining flexible to embrace innovative omnichannel technologies. 

After switching to Contentstack, Cartier experienced:

  • The development of new websites in days, not weeks

  • Ensured brand integrity throughout different initiatives

  • Greater return on investment in content assets

"The websites that are a critical part of our digital portfolio are now more aligned and performant. As a result, the customer digital experience of Cartier improves, reflecting our commitment to becoming a reference for luxury in all aspects," said Anastasia Goglova, international digital lead. To learn why Cartier chose Contentstack, read "Cartier improves brand integrity and operations efficiency."

Migrating from Sitecore to Contentstack

Migrating from Sitecore to Contentstack might seem daunting, but it can be a smooth process with a clear plan and good practices. Follow these steps to ensure a successful migration:

Analyze your current content structure

Begin by reviewing your existing Sitecore content structure and taxonomy. This will help you determine the necessary updates and changes to implement in Contentstack.

Prepare a migration plan

Define a clear roadmap, including timelines, scope, responsibilities, and corresponding tasks. Consider hiring an implementation partner with experience in both Sitecore and Contentstack for a seamless transition.

Map content models

Correctly map and classify Sitecore content fields to equivalent Contentstack content types. Remember that Contentstack's modular blocks allow a more flexible content modeling approach.

Develop custom scripts 

Develop scripts to extract, transform, and load data (ETL) from Sitecore to Contentstack. Plan and execute testing rounds to ensure accurate data migration.

Optimize your digital assets 

Use Contentstack's digital asset management capabilities to organize and optimize your digital assets, such as images, videos, and documents, during migration.

Update front-end code

Modify or rewrite your front-end code to consume the APIs provided by Contentstack. Adjust content rendering according to your specific design and performance requirements.

Our industry-leading care without-compromise program and technical solutions team (TSO) will be available to assist you throughout the process as follows:

  • Dedicated account management

  • Real-time, 24/7 in-app human support

  • Tailored workshops and advisory consultations

  • Regular health checks and performance reviews 

  • And so much more

Make the switch

With its flexible architecture, ease of use, and extensive feature set, Contentstack is an excellent option for businesses that want to stay ahead of the curve. Additionally, with the end-of-life of Sitecore XP 10.4, there is no better time to switch to a future-proof CMS to ensure your organization remains competitive. 

Switch to Contentstack today and experience the benefits of using a composable headless CMS!

About Contentstack

The Contentstack team comprises highly skilled professionals specializing in product marketing, customer acquisition and retention, and digital marketing strategy. With extensive experience holding senior positions in notable technology companies across various sectors, they bring diverse backgrounds and deep industry knowledge to deliver impactful solutions.  

Contentstack stands out in the composable DXP and Headless CMS markets with an impressive track record of 87 G2 user awards, 6 analyst recognitions, and 3 industry accolades, showcasing its robust market presence and user satisfaction.

Check out our case studies to see why industry-leading companies trust Contentstack.

Experience the power of Contentstack's award-winning platform by scheduling a demo, starting a free trial, or joining a small group demo today.

Follow Contentstack on Linkedin

Share on:

Talk to an expert

about something you read on this page

Contact an expert

Recommended posts